Worst Title Defences in F1

by Craig Normansell on Mar 15th, 2011

The 2011 season is just round the corner, and with the start of an F1 campaign usually begins with writers talking up the chances of the champion retaining.Seb Vettel beware, as the vaults of Grand Prix racing holds several stories of champs failing to match their feats of the season before. Whether it be poor form, a poor machine under them or just a poor attitude, the Badgerometer is back and ready to count down these tales of riches to rags!

 

Jacques Villenueve

1997  81 points (Champion) -- 1998 21 points (5th)

Canada's only F1 champion to date won a closely fought battle with Michael Schumacher to win in 1997. The following season, his Williams team was in disarray with the withdrawl of long term engine supplier Renault and the smart Rothmans blue being replaced with the garish Winfield red (not that colours affect race cars, we at Badger just hated it).

The usual development pace of the Grove team was also poor, with rumours that the 1998 car was the same as the previous seasons, with modifications to fit the new regulations. The only race where the Canadian challenged for the lead was at the start in Belgium, but when Coulthard binned it (and everyone else) Jacques was eliminated at the re-start. A pair of late season podiums was the best he could manage, before slinking off to the new BAR team in '99.

Mario Andretti

1978 - 64 points (Champion) -- 1979 14 points (12th)

America's last great Grand Prix driver had the might of Colin Chapman behind him during the '70's, and with ground effect starting to become the must-have gadget of the time the Lotus man didn't disappoint with the Lotus 79. Five wins in 1978 for Andretti made the 79 the class of the field, and it was thought that the follow up to it, the Lotus 80, would push the boundaries of grip even further.

Of course, as with all things Grand Prix, that was not the case. The Lotus 80, although innovative, was a disaster. Mario managed a podium on it's first outing but it was too reliant on ground effect and mid-season the team switched back to the 79, but by then the rest of the field had caught up (and surpassed) the British outfit and the American only managed another 5th place finish before the season's end. Andretti managed two more full seasons in F1, one with Alfa Romeo, and a few cameos for Williams and Ferrari before returning to IndyCar for the twilight of his career.

Damon Hill

1996 - 97 points (Champion) -- 1997 7 points (12th)

After years in Schumacher's shadow, Damon Hill finally won a title for Williams in '96 after dominating all season long. But, during the negotiations for the following season, Hill held out for more money from Frank Williams and the team boss unceremoniously dumped the champion-elect for German Heinz-Harold Frentzen. With every other top team either with seats filled or unwilling to pay a large salary Hill signed for the Arrows team to defend his No.1 status.

The season, of course, wasn't exactly perfect. It took until France to finish a race and Britain before points were scored. But in Hungary, the impossible nearly happened when the combination of sticky Bridgestone tyres and Hill's expertise of the Hungaroring had him in the lead until a faulty washer slowed him to second place. After two more seasons with Jordan (including winning that Belgium race), Damon bowed out of the sport.

Jody Scheckter

1979 51 points (Champion) -- 1980 2 points (19th)

Before Jody Scheckter moved to Ferrari, he had already garnered a reputation for being a fast racing driver. He had wins to his name for both Tyrrell and Wolf and naturally when he signed for the Prancing Horse, several titles would not be far behind. With team-mate Gilles Villenueve also in great form it was expected for Ferrari to dominate in 1979, and Jody and Gilles became good friends and thrived in a great natured rivalry that produced three wins apiece. The South African countered the French Canadian's superior all out speed with a more conservative points-collecting strategy that paid off and made him World Champ.

Many factors made sure that 1980 was a far less successful year for the reigning champ. Firstly, the Ferrari chassis, which made it's debut it 1974, had been overtaken by many other teams in terms of ground effect. Only one points scoring result was achieved by Scheckter, a 5th place, and he also suffered the embarrasment of not qualifying for the Canadian Grand Prix.

The season also saw many accidents,  like the ones that left Clay Reggazoni and Jean-Pierre Jabouille seriously injured, and a testing one that cost Patrick Depailler his life. At the end of the year, with a championship to his name and the sport no longer what it once was to him, Jody retired from Grand Prix racing to set up several businesses.


"Our Nige"

1992 108 points (Champion) -- 1993 (Did not compete)

The moustached hero to many Brits was renowned for his temperamental ways, the best probably being personified in the way he retired from full-time F1. In 1992, Mansell finally sealed an F1 World Title, something that had been eluding him since 1986 and dominated the whole season in his Williams. But the politics that would follow was almost like an episode of Jeremy Kyle.

The wily Frank Williams had eyes on Alain Prost signing for 1993 (after the Frenchman took a sabbatical from Ferrari and their "truck"), but also had Ayrton Senna offering to drive for absolutely nothing. Nigel didn't like Alain after a year at Ferrari where the Brit accused the Frenchman of taking all the best parts and not sharing. Alain didn't want Ayrton after their bust-up at McLaren. Ayrton just wanted to drive the best car. Ayrton and Nigel was Frank's best option, but Alain had already signed a contract (keeping up?).

In the end, Mansell quit full-time racing rather than be Prost's team-mate, which went to Damon Hill. He found a new home in IndyCar and won that title at his first attempt, being the only man ever to hold both F1 and IndyCar titles at the same time.

Comments and Discussion

TheBrave

Love the lists badgers. I guess there was no choice but to put nige's as the worst title defense ever since he didn't even compete. It still feels a bit unfair on him though since he would have probably got a second title if he had been able to stay at williams. xD

- posted on 15th March 2011 at 7:00 pm
Tone

Hahah love it. As soon as I saw the title Villeneuve and Hill sprang to mind as 90s examples. Seems a little unfair to include Nigel as to be fair he did win A title the next year, just not the F1 title, so did technically remain a champion. I'd say it actually worked out pretty well for him overall.

- posted on 15th March 2011 at 7:42 pm
Talking about F1

Very good article.

Could also have mentioned Alberto Ascari - World Champion in 1953 (and 1952), a grand total of 1.14 points scored in 1954! The 0.14 points was for sharing a fastest lap among seven drivers (when points were awarded for such things)!

- posted on 15th March 2011 at 8:03 pm
Adam Milleneuve

there's also the slight factor that as world champion, 'our nige' believed he deserved more dollars, and Frank being frank said err, no and that didn't go down well...

- posted on 15th March 2011 at 10:12 pm
BazL

Given that Tone above reminded us that he won in an indycar the following year, can we use 1995 as the year of his title defence? You know the one where he had put on soooo much weight McLaren had to rebuild the cockpit around him!
What happened Nige?
Indycar Ron!
One race and 18 laps later - Null points! worst title defence ever - no question - and funniest!

- posted on 16th March 2011 at 10:11 am
Dave Highkinen

Could be a conspiracy! It might be that the team released a statement saying Nigel was too fat while the reality was that Nigel drove the car in testing, realised it was McLaren's biggest lemon ever and said: "I'm not driving that until you make it faster".
Possible. ;)

- posted on 16th March 2011 at 4:14 pm
Craig Normansell

Very true Tone, not only did he hold one title but then secured another to hold both at the same time.

If anyone wants to catch up with how Mansell got on in the States after F1, here's the '93 CART review:

Part 1: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CKCNM9PG-3s
Part 2: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hD625N5rrME

- posted on 16th March 2011 at 6:32 pm
Stephen

I remember Murray Walker's commentary when Villeneuve nearly took the lead at Belgium 98.
"Villeneuve, look at Villeneuve! And into the wall who was that?"
Martin Brundle "Coulthard"
"It's Coulthard!..."

- posted on 17th March 2011 at 1:24 am
TommyB89

Great post but I wouldn't have included Mansell. I guess its worst title defences "in f1" but winning the Indy Car title in your first year is pretty epic. He had to master ovals and Indy back then was a tough and competitive series just like F1.

I remember hearing the news that Damon Hill had signed to Arrows. I think I may have shed a tear.

- posted on 20th March 2011 at 1:02 am

Leave a comment

RECENT ARTICLES F1 TV Times - Monaco

F1 TV Times for the Monaco Grand Prix

MONACO-event-2012

Monaco Grand Prix LIVE in London

AU587274

Our Top 5 Monaco Grand Prix

Photo: The Cahier Archive

Graham Hill - The man they called Mister Monaco

b-and-o

WIN: Bang & Olufsen Form 2 Headphones

retrof1

WIN: Classic Monaco Grand Prix Art Prints

goodwood-fos

WIN: Goodwood Festival of Speed Tickets

b-and-o-experience

WIN: Bang & Olufsen F1 Viewing Experience

octane

WIN: F1 2012 'Champions' Poster Prints

120426010801-susie-wolff-williams-f1-horizontal-gallery

Podium or Pits? It's Grand Prix POP!

Pastor was Top Dog, but what about everyone else?

Driver Performance Analysis: Spain

Felipe Massa - 2 points

Massa Bashing: Round 5

The_Three_Stooges

The Spanish Grand Prix Hangover

303344_10151717610735198_574385197_24378349_1708065361_n

The Top 5 from Catalunya

Santander-Grid-Girls

The Best Pictures from Barcelona